The Reserve Report: Special Edition – U.S. Household Debt Hits Record High in 2024

The Federal Reserve’s latest report paints a concerning picture of U.S. household debt, reaching a staggering $17.5 trillion in Q4 2023. This marks a new record high, fueled by a 1.2% increase from the previous quarter and a significant $3.4 trillion rise since the end of 2019.

However, a closer look reveals a more nuanced story. While overall debt continues to climb, the trends vary across different categories. This analysis delves into the key findings, exploring the surge in credit card debt, the slowdown in mortgage growth, and the rise of personal loans. We’ll also examine how different generations are managing their debt burdens, with Millennials and Gen Z facing distinct challenges. By dissecting these trends, we can gain valuable insights into the current financial climate and potential future implications for U.S. consumers.

Key Findings on U.S. Household Debt

  • U.S. household debt reached a record high of $17.5 trillion in Q4 2023, a 1.2% increase from Q3 2023 and a $3.4 trillion increase since the end of 2019.
  • Mortgage debt is the largest category, rising to $12.25 trillion but with slower growth due to rising rates and limited home sales.
  • Credit card debt saw the most significant increase (17.4% in 2023) due to increased revolving debt and higher spending.
  • Auto loan debt continued its upward trend, reaching $1.61 trillion.
  • Personal loan debt experienced significant growth (over 10%) in both secured and unsecured categories.
  • Millennials and Gen Z saw the highest increases in overall debt (8% and 15.4% respectively) while older generations started reducing theirs.
  • Gen X has the highest average credit card debt ($9,123) potentially due to peak earning years and diverse credit mix.
  • Gen Z has the highest personal loan debt increase (13.4%) possibly for debt consolidation.
  • Southern states experienced the largest increases in overall debt balances, potentially due to lower average credit scores.

U.S. Household Debt Reaches Record High

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York (FRBNY) released new statistics showing that in the fourth quarter (Q4) of 2023, total household debt balances rose by $212 billion, an increase of 1.2% from the third quarter (Q3) of 2023. 

With a $3.4 trillion rise since the end of 2019, shortly before the pandemic recession, balances are currently at $17.50 trillion. 

Mortgage balances rose by $112 billion to $12.25 trillion during the quarter, while credit card balances increased by $50 billion to $1.13 trillion. At $1.61 trillion, auto loan balances increased by $12 billion, maintaining an upward trend that began in 2011. All debt types saw a rise in delinquency transition rates, except for student loans.

In addition to this, based on the Experian report, credit card debt remains the most notable area of movement in consumer credit markets as of late. In 2023, total credit card balances saw a significant increase of 17.4%. This growth can be attributed to two primary factors:

  • Increased revolving debt. The number of credit card borrowers carrying a balance from month to month has risen by 4 percentage points. This indicates a growing reliance on revolving credit to finance spending.
  • Elevated retail spending. Additional retail spending also contributed to the rise in credit card debt.

It’s important to note that nearly all credit card debt is unsecured and subject to variable interest rates. As a result, these debt products have been particularly impacted by recent interest rate hikes. This impact is expected to have broader economic consequences as we enter 2024.

Total Debt Balance by Type (Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

As of Q3 2023, mortgage debt, representing nearly two-thirds of all consumer debt, exhibited moderate growth of 3.2%, reaching $11.6 trillion. This relatively slow increase can be attributed to two key factors: rising mortgage rates and a shortage of available homes for sale due to homeowners’ hesitation to sell.

  • Mortgage – $11.58T
  • Home equity – $139.3B
  • HELOC – $326.1B
  • Student loan – $1.47T
  • Auto loan – $1.51T
  • Auto lease – $73.2 B
  • Credit card – $1.07T
  • Retail credit card – $126.9B
  • Personal loan – $571.7B

A closer look into consumer debt trends in 2023 reveals a distinct pattern within the credit card sector. Unlike other debt categories, such as student loans or mortgages, consumers were unable to defer the impact of rising interest rates on credit card debt.

Throughout 2023, the Federal Reserve’s interest rate hikes translated directly into higher interest charges for consumers carrying credit card balances. This factor, coupled with a potential increase in overall credit card usage, contributed to a significant rise in total credit card balances.

Federal Reserve just recently released the Q4 2023 household debt and credit report, and the total consumer debt reached $17.50 trillion, showing a growth rate of 1.2% from Q3 2023.

Average Consumer Debt Balance by Debt Type (Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

  • Mortgage – $244,498
  • HELOC – $42,139
  • Student loan – $38,787
  • Auto loan – $23,792
  • Credit card – $6,501
  • Retail Card – $1,188
  • Personal loan – $19,402
  • Total average balance – $104,215

Total Average Consumer Debt by State

In 2023, average debt balances rose in all states. Compared to the national average growth of 2.3%, the Southern states experienced the largest increases in overall debt balances, with average increases of 4% or more in Alabama, Florida, North Carolina, Oklahoma, South Carolina, and Texas. In comparison to other places with stronger average credit scores, these states may have lower average FICO® Scores☉, which could translate into higher total financing costs for consumers within these areas.

10 States with Highest Total Average Consumer Debt (Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

  1. District of Columbia – $166,186
  2. Colorado – $154,481
  3. Washington – $150,462
  4. California – $148,428
  5. Hawaii – $147,103
  6. Utah – $138,485
  7. Maryland – $131,948
  8. Virginia – $128,386
  9. Massachusetts – $127,277
  10. Oregon – $123,090

10 States with Lowest Total Average Consumer Debt (Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

  1. West Virginia – $64,320
  2. Mississippi – $65,547
  3. Kentucky – $73,132
  4. Arkansas – $74,770
  5. Oklahoma – $75,022
  6. Ohio – $75,243
  7. Michigan – $77,903
  8. Alabama – $77,981
  9. Indiana – $79,349
  10. Louisiana – $80,616

Total Average Debt by Generation

According to Experian data, Millennials and Generation Z saw their loan balances increase by 8% and 15.4%, respectively, while older consumers started to reduce their overall debt in 2023. In 2023, Generation X saw a slight growth of 1.9%.

Credit Card Debt by Generation

A recent study revealed distinct patterns in credit card debt across different generations in the United States. Individuals belonging to the oldest and youngest generations tend to have significantly lower average credit card balances compared to the national average.

Millennials and baby boomers, the two largest generations in the US, hold average credit card balances closer to the national average.

Generation X, individuals in their mid-40s to mid-50s, stands out with an average credit card balance of $9,123, exceeding the national average by 40%.

Generation X often coincides with peak earnings years, potentially providing them with the ability to manage higher debt levels. This generation might also have a more diverse credit mix, including student loans, mortgages, and car payments, contributing to their overall debt burden.

Average Credit Card Debt by Generation or Age (as of Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

  • Generation Z (18-26) – $3,262  
  • Millennials (27-42) – $6,521
  • Generation X (43-58) – $9,123
  • Baby boomers (59-77) – $6,642
  • Silent generation (78+) – $3,412

Total Personal Loan Debt by Type

  • Unsecured Loan  – $194.0 B
  • Secured Loan – $378.5 B

Personal loans experienced significant growth in 2023 in both secured and unsecured personal loan markets, with year-over-year increases exceeding 10%. Unsecured personal loans increased to a total debt of $194.0B (↑11.4%), while secured personal loans rose to a total of $378.5B (↑10.6%) from Q3 2022 to Q3 2023.

This surge is primarily attributed to consumers seeking debt consolidation solutions to address increasingly high-interest rates on variable-rate credit products. Notably, the average annual percentage rate (APR) for even creditworthy borrowers has surpassed 20% on these accounts.

Average Personal Loan Debt by Generation or Age (as of Q3 2023 – Experian Report)

  • Generation Z (18-26)- $8,710
  • Millennials (27-42) – $16,669
  • Generation X (43-58) – $22,259
  • Baby boomers (59-77) – $22,551
  • Silent generation (78+) – $18,547

Gen Z demonstrated the highest increase in personal loan debt, with a growth rate of 13.4% between Q3 2022 and Q3 2023. While millennials had the second-highest increase in personal loan debt, with a growth rate of 10.4% over the same period.

Expert Debt Management Tips for 2024

Although many Americans aim to pay down debt and increase savings in 2024, managing finances can be challenging. Here are expert tips on how to manage your debts.

  • List your debts. Gather all your debts, including credit cards, loans, etc. Note down the interest rate and minimum payment for each.
  • Track your spending. Use an app or spreadsheet to record everything you spend for a month. This helps identify areas to cut back.
  • Debt snowball. Pay off the smallest debts first, gaining momentum and motivation.
  • Debt avalanche. Focus on the debts with the highest interest rates first, saving money on interest in the long run.
  • Create a budget. Allocate your income towards necessities, debt repayment, and some savings (even small amounts add up!).
  • Set realistic goals. Break down your debt into smaller, achievable milestones.
  • Pay more than the minimum. Every extra dollar towards the principal reduces your debt faster and saves you interest.
  • Boost your income. Consider a side hustle, freelance work, or negotiating a raise to increase your debt-fighting resources.
  • Reduce expenses. Analyze your spending and cut back on unnecessary things like eating out, subscriptions, or impulse purchases.
  • Debt consolidation. Combine multiple debts into one loan with a potentially lower interest rate, simplifying your repayment process.
  • Balance transfer. Transfer high-interest debt to a card with a 0% introductory APR period to temporarily reduce interest charges. (Use this strategically and be mindful of fees and balance repayment after the introductory period ends.)
  • Seek professional help. Credit counselors can offer personalized advice and negotiate with creditors on your behalf.

Final Thoughts

The report shows U.S. household debt is at a record high, with credit card debt increasing the fastest. This can be stressful, but there are ways to manage it. Track your spending, create a budget, and prioritize paying off high-interest debts first (avalanche method) or the smallest debts first (snowball method) to feel motivated. Explore options like debt consolidation or balance transfers to see if they can help you save on interest. Remember, there’s help available. Credit counselors can offer personalized advice and negotiate with creditors on your behalf. Don’t be afraid to seek help and take control of your financial future.


Sources: